Reviewer’s Form


Przegląd Techniczny

ul. Czackiego 3/5 lok 114

00-043 Warszawa

tel. (22) 336-14-67

redakcja@przeglad-techniczny.pl

www.przeglad-techniczny.pl

 

Name of the Reviewer (degree, position):                        

Business/Home address:                                                           

 

Telephone:                            

Email:                                   

 

Reviewer’s Form

No of paper:   

Title of paper:                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        

                                                                                                                                

Date of paper reception by Review:                                                

Date of paper return to the editor:   

 

 

1. Is the paper relevant for publishing in the Przegląd Techniczny?

 

2. Is the paper presenting a current state of the art of the discussed subject?

 

3. What is the main thesis of the paper? What is the scientific value of this thesis? Are there any mistakes or errors in thesis definition and analysis?

 

4. Is the paper written in an understandable way? Are the terminology and abbreviations used properly?

 

5. Is there any need to introduce changes to the paper? If yes, what changes?

 

6. Is there any possibility or need to shorten the paper (including decrease in the number of equations, figures, tables)? Please, indicate the possible material that can be omitted.  

 

7. Detailed remarks of the Reviewer

 

 

Date and Reviewers signature

Komentuje Waldemar Rukść

eNOT.pl - Portal Naczelnej Organizacji Technicznej | eNOT.pl